Criminology Assignment


Provide a description of potential ethical challenges in the Kennedy scenario from your resources this week. Based on your experience or research, do you believe the police officers involved in the scenario should have known their actions were questionable? Again, from your experience or research, what disciplinary action, if any, do you believe would be appropriate for this situation? Do you believe the letter from the chief of police to the citizens of Ft. Worth, Texas, was an adequate response to the situation? Why or why not? Finally, explain how leadership might have changed the outcome of the scenario by demonstrating integrity and ethics.

Here’s the Scenario Article to use for assignment
Kennedy, B. (2013, November 20). Fort Worth police stopped motorists—to gather saliva and blood samples? Star-Telegram. Retrieved from


Ethical Challenges: Kennedy Scenario

The article, written by Kennedy, indicates that a state agency required samples of the citizen`s blood, breath, and saliva. Therefore, Fort Worth off-duty police officers stopped drivers to collect blood and saliva samples (Kennedy, 2013). Was ethical since they infringed on the citizen`s right to privacy. Consequently, they may have caused the individuals psychological damage.


I think the police officers involved should have known their actions were questionable since during their training they learned about laws governing individual privacy and they are aware it is a tort. The law states that the person who intentionally infringes on the other`s right to privacy is subject to liability to the concerned party for invading their privacy. Therefore, the plaintiff may claim damages for feeling anguished and powerless or any emotional torcher (Sharp, 2013). Hence I believe the police officers should have faced the law as stated.

I do not believe the chief of police’sletter to the citizens of Ft. Worth, Texas responded adequately to the situation particularly in regards to the issue of laws that intrude into an individual’s private life. Ethically, collecting saliva and blood samples is intruding into the person’s privacy.Before obtaining this floods the person receiving the blood and saliva samples should provide in writing on what they intend to use the samples for and the method of disposing of them after use. The recipient of search fluid should also warranty the donor that they will share neither the samples nor the laboratory test outcome with a third party without consent.

The government ought to have rescued the situation through taking disciplinary action on the concerned parties, after which, it is advisable that they inform the public on how the method of disposing of the samples. Then educated the citizens on their rights of privacy.


Kennedy, B. (2013). Fort Worth police stopped motorists — to gather saliva and blood samples? Star-Telegram.

Sharp, T. (2013, June 12). Right to Privacy: Constitutional Rights & Privacy Laws. Retrieved from

Get a 10% discount on an order above $50